Loading Unbrokered…
Loading Unbrokered…
82 insurance / financial services employers in Indiana have substantive broker records on their Form 5500 filings. Median disclosed broker cost in this group runs about $12 per participant per month. Open any company to see its broker of record, disclosed compensation, and benefit lines — or step back to all Indiana employers.
| Company | Industry | Plan type | Participants | Latest filing | Broker comp |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ONEMAIN GENERAL SERVICES CORPORATION | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 8.9K | 2024 | Disclosed |
| CREDIT UNION CONSORTIUM | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 3.3K | 2025 | Disclosed |
| CNO SERVICES LLC | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 3.3K | 2025 | Disclosed |
| IDA INSURANCE TRUST | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 2.8K | 2024 | Disclosed |
| DENTAL PRACTICE CONSORTIUM | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 2.7K | 2025 | Disclosed |
| AMERICAN UNITED LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 2.4K | 2024 | Disclosed |
| HOOSIER INVESTMENTS, LLC | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 2.3K | 2025 | Disclosed |
| NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANIES | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 2K | 2024 | Disclosed |
| FIRST MERCHANTS CORPORATION | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 2K | 2025 | Disclosed |
| ALLIED SOLUTIONS LLC | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 1.7K | 2025 | Disclosed |
| IBA GROUP INSURANCE TRUST | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 1.5K | 2024 | Disclosed |
| GROUP 1001 RESOURCES, LLC | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 1.4K | 2025 | Disclosed |
| ALACRITY SOLUTIONS GROUP, LLC | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 1.4K | 2025 | Disclosed |
| UNITED FARM FAMILY LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 1.3K | 2025 | Disclosed |
| MEDPRO GROUP INC. | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 1.2K | 2025 | Disclosed |
| BOARD OF TRUSTEE ISC OF PLASTERERS & CEMENT MASON HEALTH & WELFARE | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 1.2K | 2024 | Disclosed |
| CENTIER BANK | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 1.1K | 2025 | Disclosed |
| FIRST FINANCIAL CORPORATION | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 939 | 2025 | Disclosed |
| MEDICAL PRACTICE CONSORTIUM | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 909 | 2024 | Disclosed |
| ONEAMERICA AGENTS' ASSOCIATION, INC | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 794 | 2024 | Disclosed |
| THE BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF THE ICSO GROUP HEALTH & WELFARE PLAN | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 745 | 2024 | Disclosed |
| ICI BENEFITS CONSORTIUM | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 736 | 2024 | Disclosed |
| MERCHANTS BANCORP | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 733 | 2025 | Disclosed |
| EVERWISE CREDIT UNION | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 719 | 2025 | Disclosed |
| BROTHERHOOD MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 703 | 2025 | Disclosed |
| SANCTUARY WEALTH GROUP, LLC | Insurance / Financial Services | Fully insured | 585 | 2025 | Disclosed |
| DOXA INSURANCE HOLDINGS, LLC | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 569 | 2025 | Disclosed |
| SHEPHERD INSURANCE, LLC | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 532 | 2025 | Disclosed |
| PROTECTIVE INSURANCE CORPORATION | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 498 | 2022 | Disclosed |
| THREE RIVERS FEDERAL CREDIT UNION | Insurance / Financial Services | Fully insured | 490 | 2025 | Disclosed |
| STAR FINANCIAL GROUP, INC. | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 453 | 2024 | Disclosed |
| RUOFF MORTGAGE COMPANY, INC. | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 445 | 2025 | Disclosed |
| RENAISSANCE ACQUISITION COMPANY, LLC | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 436 | 2025 | Disclosed |
| CENTRA CREDIT UNION | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 422 | 2025 | Disclosed |
| FIRST INTERNET BANK | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 355 | 2025 | Disclosed |
| SAC FINANCE INC | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 346 | 2025 | Disclosed |
| HMR ACQUISITION COMPANY, INC. | Insurance / Financial Services | Fully insured | 329 | 2024 | Disclosed |
| THE NATIONAL BANK OF INDIANAPOLIS | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 314 | 2025 | Disclosed |
| KEY FAMILY OF COMPANIES | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 308 | 2024 | Disclosed |
| GVC MORTGAGE, INC. | Insurance / Financial Services | Fully insured | 286 | 2023 | Disclosed |
| PURDUE EMPLOYEES FEDERAL CREDIT UNION | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 283 | 2025 | Disclosed |
| FULL-O-PEP APPLIANCES, INCORPORATED | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 272 | 2025 | Disclosed |
| CENTRAL TRUCKING, INC. | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 265 | 2024 | Disclosed |
| INTERNATIONAL MEDICAL GROUP | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 265 | 2022 | Disclosed |
| ROYAL UNITED MORTGAGE, LLC | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 257 | 2025 | Disclosed |
| FIRST SAVINGS BANK | Insurance / Financial Services | Fully insured | 251 | 2024 | Disclosed |
| INDIANA FARMERS MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 250 | 2025 | Disclosed |
| ARLINGTON/ROE & CO., INC. | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 236 | 2024 | Disclosed |
| NOTRE DAME FEDERAL CREDIT UNION | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 232 | 2025 | Disclosed |
| FLODRAULIC GROUP, INC. | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 224 | 2024 | Disclosed |
| HERITAGE FEDERAL CREDIT UNION | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 209 | 2025 | Disclosed |
| MJ INSURANCE, INC. | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 195 | 2025 | Disclosed |
| BAYLOR TRUCKING INC. | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 193 | 2024 | Disclosed |
| MIDWEST AMERICA FEDERAL CREDIT UNION | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 190 | 2024 | Disclosed |
| VALEO FINANCIAL ADVISORS LLC | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 189 | 2025 | Disclosed |
| ELEMENTS FINANCIAL FEDERAL CREDIT UNION | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 189 | 2025 | Disclosed |
| PEOPLES BANK, SB | Insurance / Financial Services | Fully insured | 188 | 2024 | Disclosed |
| OXFORD FINANCIAL GROUP, LTD | Insurance / Financial Services | Fully insured | 187 | 2025 | Disclosed |
| INDIANA UNIVERSITY CREDIT UNION | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 185 | 2024 | Disclosed |
| GIBSON INSURANCE AGENCY, INC. | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 185 | 2025 | Disclosed |
| UNIFIED GROUP SERVICES, INC. | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 179 | 2024 | Disclosed |
| HALLMARK HOME MORTGAGE, LLC | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 177 | 2025 | Disclosed |
| MDWISE, INC. | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 174 | 2025 | Disclosed |
| JACKSON COUNTY BANK | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 172 | 2024 | Disclosed |
| FIRST HARRISON BANK | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 172 | 2024 | Disclosed |
| GREGORY & APPEL, INC. | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 168 | 2024 | Disclosed |
| GREENFIELD BANKING COMPANY | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 164 | 2025 | Disclosed |
| PARTNERS 1ST FEDERAL CREDIT UNION | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 162 | 2025 | Disclosed |
| PRECISION MEDICAL TECHNOLOGIES, INC. | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 153 | 2025 | Disclosed |
| FORUM CREDIT UNION | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 149 | 2025 | Disclosed |
| PHYSICIANS HEALTH PLAN OF NORTHERN INDIANA, INC. | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 148 | 2024 | Disclosed |
| CREA, LLC | Insurance / Financial Services | Fully insured | 134 | 2025 | Disclosed |
| SIHO HOLDING INC. | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 134 | 2024 | Disclosed |
| ASH BROKERAGE, LLC | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 129 | 2022 | Disclosed |
| CITIZENS BANK | Insurance / Financial Services | Fully insured | 126 | 2024 | Disclosed |
| CEDAR HOLDINGS, INC. | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 123 | 2025 | Disclosed |
| SPRINGS VALLEY BANK & TRUST COMPANY | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 123 | 2025 | Disclosed |
| SEVEN CORNERS, INC. | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 118 | 2025 | Disclosed |
| FIRST BANK OF BERNE | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 114 | 2025 | Disclosed |
| FARMERS STATE BANK | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | 106 | 2025 | Disclosed |
| IPALCO ENTERPRISES, INC. VEBA COMMITTEE | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | — | 2024 | Disclosed |
| CONSTRUCTION INDUSTRY WELFARE FUND | Insurance / Financial Services | Self-funded | — | 2021 | Disclosed |
Sourced from Form 5500 filings as submitted to the U.S. Department of Labor. Dataset refreshed October 7, 2026. Plan years are labeled by the year they begin, so a July 2024 – June 2025 plan year is 2024. Filings may lag 12–18 months behind the current plan year.